I couldn't find Dave Richard's specific tier rankings in the wiki — that analyst's work isn't covered here. However, I can tell you what the wiki does say about McCaffrey's standing:
McCaffrey is currently ranked RB8 in FantasyPros consensus PPR rankings (as of May 2026), and the wiki describes him as a player who could "easily post another RB1 season" but carries significant risk. Kyle Shanahan has publicly stated the team will reduce McCaffrey's workload in 2026, and his rushing efficiency declined in 2025 (ranked 35th in explosive run rate, 40th in yards after contact). At age 30, most analysts have him sliding out of the top-tier conversation — Sal Vetri on the Fantasy Footballers' channel ranked him as his RB3 in a recent video, , while Fantasy Football Today flagged him as a potential bust at his ADP citing the 400-touch workload concern, .